I know this is my day to do Thursday 13. BUT. I have some more important things to discuss.
The Hunger Games.
If you haven't read the books, don't read on. I'm giving you a clear warning - spoiler alert!
Okay. Hardly any of my friends have read the series, so I'm DYING to discuss it with someone. I want to hear your thoughts too! Please don't judge me for being so completely invested in fiction books written for 14 year olds.
Some things I loved:
- The characters. I felt like I knew them. I was completely invested in their fictional lives.
- The story line. I know it's really weird and kind of gruesome. But it was original, and I liked it.
- Peeta. I am team Peeta. He kind of made my heart melt.
- That Katniss wasn't perfect. She was screwed up and indecisive and normal. I like characters like that.
- All three books. Even though the series didn't end exactly like I wanted it to, I still thought all three books were great, and I couldn't put them down.
- The fact that I was so completely invested in the story. I may have cried at a couple moments. It's true.
- All the weird names. Katniss. Peeta. Prim. Boggs. Cinna. Haymitch. They're so weird and wonderful.
- That you could relate to the characters. Even though the situations were weird and nothing like my life, I could still understand the emotions of all the characters.
Some things I didn't like:
- The very end. I was just so disappointed that the ending wasn't very happy. Yes, she ended up with Peeta and they got to have a life together. But I don't feel like she ever got to be happy. Even in the epilogue, she's still having nightmares 20 years later and just seemed so tortured. It made me sad.
- All the killing. As an adult, I really liked the story line and its originality. But as a teacher, I'm not sure I would want kids reading that much violence. I guess there are a lot of good points that can be made from it. But I'm just not sure I like it.
- The author's shortcuts. One thing that really frustrated me was how a couple different times, Katniss blacked out and woke up to a completely different world. Like in the very end. She's in the battle, and all the sudden she wakes up to find that her sister is dead, the Capitol is overthrown, Snow isn't president, and on and on. I felt almost like the author got stuck and was just like "Okay, let's have her black out and I'll explain this all away." And again at the end of the 3rd book, when she's stuck in her room during the trial and after when she's wandering around in a stupor. We didn't know anything, and then it just lays it on and explains in one paragraph that all of these major things happened. I felt like that at the end of the 2nd book as well. After they snatched her from The Hunger Games, and then explained away the whole book and told all about the secret plots that had been happening. I know we're reading it from Katniss' perspective, so technically we wouldn't know about any of it. But I still felt like I was cheated out of reading a bunch of good stuff. Does that make sense? Did you guys feel like that?
- Prim's death. I didn't like that she died. But I especially didn't like how the author handled it. I felt like they should have spent a lot more time talking about it. But instead, when Katniss woke up, it was kind of like "Oh by the way, your sister is dead. Okay. Let's move on." The entire ending felt a little rushed.
- Both boys' endings. Even though I wasn't rooting for Gale, I still loved him and wanted him to be happy. But we got no closure. He just drifted off to another district, all sad and lonely and never got to talk to Katniss again. And I didn't really like Peeta's ending either. Yes, I'm glad he and Katniss ended up together and in the epilogue we found out he got to have a relitively happy life. But I feel like we never got to see him being "normal Petta" again. After we were disconnected from him through the whole 3rd book, I thought we'd get to see a little more of him at the end. Instead, the last real memory of him we have is all the way back in the 2nd book.
So PLEASE tell me. What did you think?



9 comments!:
I was in total "hunger games" world for awhile... loved the books. loved the story... totally invested.
But I HATED HATED HATED the last book. The "revolution" stuff was just too much. I didnt care for a revolt/war story. I loved the others that involved their survival in a game - working together - but against each other. SUch good dynamics.
I didnt care for the "black outs" either. Too easy...
And the end really didnt really "fit" for me... their relationships all still seemed out of context with the first 2 books.
I loved the idea of the book though (cant you see that happening with the way reality TV goes?)
I ADORED Peeta... swooned so many times over him.
Katniss definitely wasnt your ordinary gal.
I'm just excited about the movie!!! Hope it does the books justice!
i loved the books as well and agree with your assessments. i remember having to actually go back and reread where Prim died. It was so nonchalant and should have been a much bigger deal. I didn't like the shortcuts either. but overall, i really did love the books. they are a big hit at my school right now. not sure what that says about us, but......
there is another series that i haven't read, but have heard is similar and great as well. the first book in the series is called "the maze runner." have you read it or heard of it? if not, check it out and let me know what you think.
i love that you read these books. it makes me happy. we should have a teenage-book-club for adults. :)
I have been dying to read this series. Thanks for reminding me, going to add it to my list, thanks!
I'm already wanting to go back and reread the series. Just a few thoughts...
I loved, loved, loved Peeta. "swooning" is the perfect word. Sigh...
I have to say that I actually really liked the ending. I think Prim had to die, it's the entire reason the book happened and if she were "saved" it would be too perfect of an ending. And it wasn't a "happy ending" book. There was too much psychological damage for any character to end up normal.
I don't think this should be considered a young adult book (I wouldn't let a young adult read it!) but I thought it was a wonderful commentary on our society. I agree with Rebecca that I don't think our society could be too far off... It's happened before and with reality tv so popular...
I think Katniss' character is why the book is so wonderful. She is so honest and so real and so faulted. It's refreshing to see such a messed up character. ha!
Anyway, love love loved it! Not excited for the movie though. Jennifer Lawrence? Gah I can't get over it!!!
this is seriously the best series ever! katniss is just a bad-a** and i love it! the plot was great, i liked the bit of romance thrown in and the "thunder dome" idea, so perfect! i think i might re-read it just relive it all! awww i love reading :D
xo,
cb
okay! here goes!
1. what is up with those names?
Peeta? I thought of Pita bread. Katniss...Katnip (of course!) and Haymich...I called him Sandwich. I think I might be the weird one.
2. The third book was such a downer. Seriously. It was like the author got tired of writing...I kept thinking that I had missed something because some important things happened while people were "Sleeping" and then like you said, she just brushed by them. I really did think that I had skipped a part of the book because situations were just not discussed enough-like Prim's death.
3. This series was like a creepy George Orwell's 1984 meets Survior. It was strange.
4. I liked the first book but they went downhill after that. :(
I love the Hunger Games Series! I defnitely would agree with you about the blacking out parts. I really wanted to read how things hapened, no just be told. Also, book 3 was my least favorite. It was just so different from the other two! - Alyssa
My world was taken over by these books as well. I think the author did an excellent job writing in the first person...I felt like I was experiencing everything Katniss did; from her desperation when volunteering at the Reaping to save Prim, her struggle with her feelings for Peeta and Gale, realizing she loved Peeta, and her psychotic split at the end when she loses Prim. I don't think the author intended the glossing over of Prim's death to be an easy way out. I think that Katniss was broken at that point, and couldn't relive it again to explain it. She became, in many ways, like Annie.
Neither Katniss nor Peeta ever get back to those people we first meet in The Hunger Games, but they find each other again, in their new incarnations, and build a life together. In their way, they're as happy as they can be given what they lived through, but part of them is damaged forever....it is sad, and meant to be.
Also a comment on the names. This is supposed to be set sometime in the future. Look how odd names are getting nowadays....Mowgli, Pilot, Apple, Maddox. People will continue to find unique names because they want something different...so the names in the book make sense to me. It's the direction we're heading now....
Post a Comment